|Portrayed by||Torianna Lee|
|Elise Nichols gallery|
Elise Nichols was Garret Jacob Hobbs' last victim, before he killed his wife Louise Hobbs and attempted to kill his daughter Abigail Hobbs.
When Will and Jack visit her family's home, her parents are distraught, but hold on to the frail hope that their daughter Elise is still alive. Will asks the parents if their cat has been acting odd since the abduction. When she disappeared, Elise was due to come home to look after the family cat. When Will finds out the cat was acting normally, Will knows Elise fed him before the crime and concludes the abduction occurred at the family house. When Will enters Elise's bedroom with her father, he finds a deceased Elise lying tranquilly in her bed. Her father drops the cat. The killer brought her corpse back.